The two short stories, the gift of the magi written by o henry and the necklace written by guy de maupassant are both composed of two young, beautiful women mathilde and della. Hand out copies of the gift of the magi and venn diagrams students take out the necklace and review main plot points, irony explain that students will be comparing the two stories using the 6 elements of literature plus irony and charting them on the venn diagram as they read. A difference in the two stories is the main characters, della (the gift of the magi) and mathilde loisel (the necklace) della is a loving wife who works very hard to try and surprise her husband with a christmas gift. The gift of the magi the gift of the magi is one of o henry's most famous stories included in the four million, his first collection of short stories, in 1906, it has been. The gift of the magi was originally published in 1906, in o henry's second collection of short stories, the four million the gift of the magi is probably his greatest hit, and displays all of the major o henry traits in abundance.
The gift of the magi is a well-known short story by american short story writer o henry, the pen name of william sydney porter the story first appeared in the new york sunday world on december 10, 1905 and was later published in o henry's collection the four million on april 10, 1906. The main character in the necklace's, and the main character in the gift of the magi's, personalities differ from one another vastly in the necklace, the main character mathilde loisel is an ungrateful middle class woman who seeks riches and admiration. The author calls his story the gift of the magi because he wants to emphasize value of the gift and appreciate the characters: jim and della the value of the gift is emphasized in the story della sells her cascade of brown waters to buy jim a platinum chain. In the short stories the necklace and the gift of the magi, who can mme loisel and della be compared to (in terms of other literary works)as part of the essay that i am required to write, i.
The gift of the magi is one of interesting short story which is i have already read therefore, i decided to chose this short story as my mid-term paper in this paper i will be explaining all of the elements in this short story and those elements are plot, arrangement, point of view, narrator, character and settings. Short story 'the gift of the magi' by o henry the short story is centralised around the financially unstable dillingham family, who sacrifice what each hold dear about each other in order to buy gifts which complement the respective possessions, only to discover that the possessions are sold in order to buy the gifts. The gift of the magi by o henry directions: read the short story and answer the questions that follow refer to the text to check your answers when appropriate. The gift of the magi is featured in our collections: christmas stories and short stories for middle school if you enjoyed it, try giovanni boccaccio's federigo's falcon , and the necklace , both employing ironic twists, and great examples for comparative analysis.
The irony in the short stories, the necklace and the gift of the magi, ought to be further analyzed through examination of this element in literature the reader can derive many morals and themes that could be useful in their own lives. You are here: home / standards for reading literature / literature exemplars - grades-9-10 / short story study guides / short stories for teaching symbolism / teacher's guide: an analysis of the necklace by guy de maupassant with a summary of the necklace and the necklace activities and lesson plans. Cc regents exam - part 3 text analysis based on one short story gift of the magi analysis of what text says as well as. The gift of the magi and the necklace share particular similarities in characters, irony and theme in both stories the main characters, della and mathilde, share similar characteristics both are young, and married to very loving and caring husbands.
O h e n r y when the name was placed there, mr james dillingham young was being paid $30 a week now, when he was being paid only $20 a week, the name seemed too long and important. Comparison essay the two short stories, the gift of the magiã â written by o henry and the necklace written by guy de maupassant are both composed of two young, beautiful women mathilde and della. The couple in the gift of the magi is della and jim dillingham jim and della are young and poor yet infected by the culture of abundance felt during the industrialization and consumerism at the beginning of 20th century america. Open document below is an essay on comparison between the necklace and the gift of the magi from anti essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples.
Pair the necklace with the gift of the magi and ask students to compare and contrast the message and theme of each 9th grade short story 860l the model millionaire. An analysis of the short stories the gift of the magi and the necklace a comparison of the stories of the necklace and the gift of the magi an analysis. The gift of the magi and its background mindy phillips introduction to literature eng125 instructor julie alfaro january 21st, 2013 in my paper i am going to be describing the short story the gift of the magi.
The gift of the magi and the necklace are two stories with a lot in common, and a lot of differences as well this unit is designed to help students uncover those as they come up with an overall theme that covers them both. The gift of the magi is a touching short story about a couple that wants to buy each other meaningful christmas presents with very little money delia sells her long, beautiful hair in order to buy her husband, jim, a gold watch chain, while jim sells his gold watch to buy delia a set of combs that she has always wanted.
Find a minimum of three examples of the use of the number three in the story other than 1) the three characters 2) the three magi and 3) the three valuables in the story, ie jim's watch, della's hair, and the love that the characters share. The gift of the magi is a well-known short story by american short story writer o henry, the pen name of william sydney porter the story first appeared in the new york sunday world on december. The theme of the gift of magi is that love is the only thing in life which can happiness along with sacrificejim and della portrays this through their love for each other by buying the gifts which they actually require the utmost but by sacrificing the things which they actually need in their love only to express their love for each other. Assessment for o henry's short story, the gift of the magi test includes 8 vocabulary matching problems, 4 multiple choice questions and 3 short-answer questions for deeper analysis includes answer key.